So, on Christmas break, I am sitting watching "Morning Joe." The gathered pundits unanimously agreed with Thomas Friedman's op-ed in yesterdays (Sunday) NY Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/28/opinion/28friedman.html?_r=1
This piece advocates a new tax on gasoline - "Win, win, win..."
So which is it? Either we have the worst economy in <fill in the blank> years... the incoming administration is lamenting thousands, if not millions of jobs being lost. The auto companies and financial services companies have fallen and likely many of them won't get up. And the answer is...
a new gas tax!
What kind of thinking takes the ONLY thing that is propping the economy now (gas is 1/2 the price it was 5 months ago), and taxes it thereby driving prices up suddenly? Where will the resulting revenue go? Into the "stimulus"? Why the stimulus is "public works projects." Don't those workers drive to work using gas? Don't they use heavy equipment that pollutes and uses gas? Don't they spread asphalt and other petro-based products?
What is the point? Government-based employment and nothing more.
Friedman and the Morning Joe crew point out that increasing prices fosters conservation. That is incredibly convoluted thinking.
What they evidently don't realize is that low gas prices drive the economy. Guys and gals - people use their cars to commute to work, to drive to meetings, to go to the supermarket to buy food, etc. This isn't about curbing Sunday driving. How many more layoffs would result from another tax on gasoline?
This would be akin to raising income taxes in this economic climate. Oh, wait a minute, the great David Axelrod came out yesterday and said that the Bush tax cut might be repealed early. Let's throw an income tax increase - maybe state taxes too - along with a new tax on gasoline - new tolls on the Garden State Parkway - and see where that gets us in terms of emerging from this collapse. Could this be about the political capital gained by simply blaming Bush for everything - the media will let this repeat for the next 8 years.
Let's keep our eye on the ball here. The currently lower gas prices are an opportunity. Not to increase taxes, but to search for alternatives while still retaining some level of economic opportunity and activity. Let's set a short deadline (how about 3 years instead of 20, 30, never...) for selecting a technology - that will create private sector jobs. The kind that actually pay taxes instead of spending tax "revenues."
These pundits are scary. Their logic shows a complete detachment from actual American life. Anyone looking to more government to solve their problems will be sadly disappointed.
Happy New Year! It is strange out there - and getting stranger.